Which is Better: Pressure Treated Fence Posts or Cedar Fence Posts for a Wood Fence?

Pressure Treated Fence Posts: Durable and Cost-Effective

Pressure treated posts are a popular choice for wood fencing due to their affordability and ability to withstand the elements. These posts are made from pine or other softwoods that have been chemically treated to resist rot, decay and insect damage.

• Long-Lasting Durability: Pressure treated wood is engineered to endure harsh conditions, including moisture and pests, making it an excellent choice for posts in direct contact with the ground.
• Budget-Friendly: Compared to cedar, pressure treated posts are more affordable, making them an ideal option for homeowners seeking a durable fence at a reasonable cost.
• Natural Weathering: While pressure treated posts don’t perfectly match the warm tones of cedar panels at first, they will naturally weather over time to a neutral gray which blends fairly well with existing fencing.

Though pressure treated posts may lack the natural charm of cedar, their strength and longevity make them a practical, no-nonsense choice for most projects.

Cedar Fence Posts: Naturally Beautiful

Cedar is renowned for its natural beauty and resistance to decay, thanks to the aromatic oils within the wood. These qualities make cedar an attractive option for homeowners seeking a classic, elegant look for their fence.

• Aesthetic Appeal: Cedar’s warm tones and fine grain provide a polished, timeless appearance that complements a wide range of styles – including post & rail, open spaced picket, privacy screen and more.
• Moderate Resistance: Cedar has some natural resistance to rot and insects, but it doesn’t hold up quite as well as pressure treated wood when exposed to soil and moisture over long periods.
• Upfront Cost: Cedar posts are generally more expensive than pressure treated ones, which may be a consideration for budget-conscious homeowners.

Fence Armor Sleeves: Luxury that Lasts

While cedar’s natural appeal is undeniable, its durability in the ground can be a concern. For homeowners who want to improve the longevity of their cedar posts, Fence Armor Sleeves are an option. With their a durable outer layer and inner airtight seal, these dual-layer protective sleeves can help shield the base of your posts from environmental factors like moisture, decay and pests as well as damage from mowers, string trimmers and other lawn equipment. While this upgrade can make cedar posts last as long as pressure-treated posts, it also adds to the overall cost of the project, which is something to weigh carefully when making your decision.

Which Should You Choose?

The right choice depends on your goals and preferences. Review these key points when considering your options:

Choose Pressure Treated Posts If:

• You need a durable and cost-effective solution.
• A slight color mismatch between posts and panels is acceptable as the posts weather naturally.
• You want a low-maintenance option that will stand the test of time.

Choose Cedar Posts If:

• You value a cohesive, natural look that pairs beautifully with cedar panels.
• You’re willing to prioritize aesthetics over cost and long-term durability.
• You’re open to adding protective measures, like Fence Armor Sleeves, to enhance the lifespan of the posts.

At Colonial Fence, we’re committed to helping you build a fence that meets your needs, style and budget. Whether you prefer the durability of pressure treated posts or the classic appeal of cedar, we’ll work with you to bring your vision to life.

Contact us using the form here on our website or give us a call at 1-800-696-8934, to start planning your perfect wood fence today.